Thursday, January 11, 2018

BEFORE WE WERE YOURS by Lisa Wingate

Happy New Year Book Club Babes!

Hope everyone had a really wonderful Christmas with family and friends and that you have an equally smashing New Years Eve.

A few weeks ago we met at Susan's beautiful home and had our yearly Christmas brunch. Bonnie Jean, Lindsay, Pam B., Pat, along with myself and Susan were in attendance. Again, thank you Susan for hosting us, we really had a wonderful time and, those of us who stuck around to hot tub were there until 4:30!

Our book this month was BEFORE WE WERE YOURS.  It was a pretty quick read and well received by all of us. The story was based on a real woman (Georgia Tann) and true events, which took place over the course of thirty years (1920's-50's) in Tennessee in which mostly small children and infants were, in some cases, quite literally, stolen from their destitute parents. Parents of new borns could also be conned at the hospital, upon the baby's delivery by signing papers they did not understand and which gave custody to Georgia Tann's whose agency was known as the Tennessee Children's Home Society.  Even though this story was fiction it gave a very good insight into what these children and their families probably experienced. Georgia Tann and her staff were neither kind nor loving and the stories that  would eventually come to light are pretty harrowing.

In all honesty, we didn't really spend a lot of time discussing the book but, all agreed that we liked it very much. The book was told in two narratives, one past and one in the present.  We  found the story about the kidnapped children from the Foss family riveting. The arch, tying the two stories together, between the children who were kidnapped back in 1939 to the granddaughter of one of those girls was well done and both stories were very good.

Collectively our rating was a 4.08.

MISTBORN: THE FINAL EMPIRE by Brandon Sanderson

We met to discuss Mistborn: The Final Empire on Friday November 3, 2017

The genre of the book is fantasy, and it took some of us a while to settle into the world depicted in the story, with trouble visualizing the fantasy world in which it was set.  It left us wanting more detail of the landscape, a feeling like you have an itch on your brain that you can’t quite reach.  It takes some time to get used to the magic in this book.  The magic concepts are quite unique.  Many parts were much too wordy, there was too much energy misspent on the battle scenes.  

The story definitely picked up in the last third of the book.  And for those of us that went on to read the second and third books in the series, we now see where the author was going in the first book, laying the groundwork for what is actually a much deeper and thought provoking story about social and political issues.

Reviews were mixed, ranging from 2.75 to 4.0.  This book stretched our imaginations and took the group out of our comfort zone of “ historical fiction”.